"Oh, Job, you want the friends to have mercy on you (19:21), but why don't you have mercy on us? Your language is so utterly, so uncompromsingly bleak. You know without a doubt that life is over, that the experience of pleasure and honor and fulness which you had for so long is irretrievably gone. Life is over for you as much as it was over for Othello after he had murdered his wife in a fit of jealousy.
I have so many questions to ask you, Job, before I even describe your feelings. Why couldn't you have said, like a mature professional athlete at the end of his career, 'It was a good career, but now it is over?' Ok, maybe that isn't the best analogy. Why couldn't you have been as "upbeat" as Christopher Reeve appeared to be (but was that all part of an act, too?) after his debilitating injury? Why couldn't you be grateful for the life that you had, and feed off the pleasant past memories like a wise investor can profit from wise investment decisions years after they have been made?
The past is a tricky thing, I know. It can stab you and enfeeble you. It can be a prison. But, can't it be a prism, too, that is a place of reflection of beautiful colors? Why is it, Job, that you are so utterly, doggedly committed to using your present experience of life as the interpretive template to use in summarizing the meaning of life? Don't those who have experienced a terrible divorce have the ability to say that at least some of their marriage was good, even blessed? Maybe the experience of dramatic loss is just too fresh for you, Job, and we can forgive you your intensity and sense of irreversible finality.
But that patronizes you, doesn't it, Job? I may say, "Well, Job, this intensity of feeling is only yours because you are freshly in the midst of your debilitating experience. Get some distance from it. Things will get better." If I talk like this, aren't I becoming like one of your friends, perhaps like Eliphaz in his first speech, where he just urged patience on you? Surely time gives us a different perspective on things, but will it change how we see the event fundamentally? Once you have been singed by the fire of the divine judgment, can you ever believe again?
So, I would like to come over to your side, Job, to see life as you see it, because I so believe that you have captured the inner springs of our emotions when loss comes our way. But if I come into your mental world, it is almost as if my own is obliterated rather than enriched. It just doesn't work for me to say, "Ok, Job, that is your experience; let me tell you about mine." I can't help getting the feeling that as you talk you speak with such authority, such claim to truth, that my truth is as pale and wan and weak as you must have felt your body was as you spoke your truth.